{"title":"Validation program: every target and its latest verdict","script":"scripts/guide-data.ts","runs":{"standard":{"file":"artifacts/validation/c7a-field1y.json","date":"2026-09-29","days":365,"seeds":[48,7,21,5,11],"burnInDays":180,"protocolHash":"4e8a1df9e91bb81d","frozenAt":"C7a","phenology":"ngogo-phenology-1998-2017"},"fresh":{"file":"artifacts/validation/c7a-fresh.json","date":"2026-09-29","days":365,"seeds":[101,202,303,404,505],"burnInDays":180,"protocolHash":"4e8a1df9e91bb81d","frozenAt":"C7a","phenology":"ngogo-phenology-1998-2017"}},"counts":{"targets":110,"fitted":37,"heldOut":73,"encoded":18,"sources":132},"summary":{"standard":{"fitted":{"fail":14,"pass":2,"tuned":1,"scale":1,"encoded":5,"inconclusive":4,"insufficient":4,"n/a":6},"held-out":{"fail":18,"compromised":3,"scale":1,"pass":8,"insufficient":7,"encoded":3,"unscorable":1,"unscored":12,"n/a":14,"inconclusive":5,"structural":1},"all":{"fail":32,"pass":10,"tuned":1,"compromised":3,"scale":2,"insufficient":11,"encoded":8,"unscorable":1,"unscored":12,"inconclusive":9,"n/a":20,"structural":1}},"fresh":{"fitted":{"fail":13,"inconclusive":9,"scale":1,"encoded":5,"insufficient":3,"n/a":6},"held-out":{"fail":15,"compromised":3,"scale":1,"pass":7,"insufficient":8,"inconclusive":8,"encoded":3,"unscorable":1,"unscored":12,"n/a":14,"structural":1},"all":{"fail":28,"inconclusive":17,"compromised":3,"scale":2,"pass":7,"insufficient":11,"encoded":8,"unscorable":1,"unscored":12,"n/a":20,"structural":1}}},"registry":{"params":772,"evidence":{"M":58,"design":577,"stylized":83,"assumed":48,"H":3,"calibrated":3},"note":"data/params.json: H/M = field studies (high / medium evidence); calibrated = fitted to targets; assumed, stylized and design = choices, labelled as such."},"datasets":[{"id":"gombe-patrols","name":"Boundary patrols and periphery visits","site":"Gombe","years":[1978,2007],"size":"180 patrols, 147 periphery visits","use":"test","licence":"CC0","cite":"Massaro et al. 2022","url":"https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.z8w9ghxdb"},{"id":"ngogo-patrols","name":"Boundary patrols and who joined","site":"Ngogo","years":[1996,2015],"size":"284 patrols, 61 males","use":"test","licence":"CC0","cite":"Langergraber et al. 2017","url":"https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.kk33f"},{"id":"tai-territory","name":"Territory sizes","site":"Taï","years":[1997,2016],"size":"53 group-years","use":"test","licence":"CC BY 4.0","cite":"Lemoine et al. 2020","url":"https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.200577"},{"id":"ngogo-phenology","name":"Tree phenology and rain","site":"Ngogo","years":[1998,2017],"size":"177,349 tree-months, 20 species","use":"build","licence":"CC0","cite":"Potts et al. 2020","url":"https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.gf1vhhmk8"},{"id":"gombe-paths","name":"15-minute focal paths","site":"Gombe","years":[2000,2003],"size":"55,076 positions, 1,330 follows","use":"test","licence":"CC0","cite":"Pusey & Schroepfer-Walker 2013","url":"https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.jg05d"},{"id":"ngogo-gps","name":"GPS ranging","site":"Ngogo","years":[2011,2023],"size":"166,826 fixes, 162 chimps","use":"test","licence":"CC BY 4.0","cite":"Sandel et al. 2026","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18603419"},{"id":"tai-movement","name":"Movement, activity and border stops","site":"Taï","years":[2013,2016],"size":"42,385 records, 625 border stops","use":"test","licence":"CC BY 4.0","cite":"Lemoine et al. 2023","url":"https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3002350"},{"id":"ngogo-fission","name":"Patrols after the split","site":"Ngogo","years":[2016,2024],"size":"36 quarters, two groups","use":"test","licence":"CC0","cite":"Sandel et al. 2026","url":"https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.sf7m0cgkg"}],"sources":{"uwimbabazi2019":{"short":"Uwimbabazi et al. 2019","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7450825/"},"villioth2025":{"short":"Villioth et al. 2025","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12701709/"},"amsler2010":{"short":"Amsler 2010","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajp.20757"},"potts2011":{"short":"Potts et al. 2011","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10764-011-9494-y"},"batesByrne2009":{"short":"Bates & Byrne 2009","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-009-0841-3"},"wilson2012":{"short":"Wilson et al. 2012","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2011.11.004"},"mitaniWatts2005":{"short":"Mitani & Watts 2005","url":"https://ngogochimpanzeeproject.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/mitani_watts_2005.pdf"},"wakefield2008":{"short":"Wakefield 2008","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10764-008-9280-7"},"wilson2007":{"short":"Wilson et al. 2007","url":"https://doi.org/10.1163/156853907782512137"},"doran1997":{"short":"Doran 1997","url":"https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026368518431"},"lehmannBoesch2008":{"short":"Lehmann & Boesch 2008","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10764-007-9230-9"},"lemoine2020b":{"short":"Lemoine et al. 2020","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7277268/"},"newtonFisher2003":{"short":"Newton‐Fisher 2003","url":"https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2028.2003.00408.x"},"williams2004":{"short":"Williams et al. 2004","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2003.09.015"},"jang2019":{"short":"Jang et al. 2019","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6667462/"},"lemoine2020a":{"short":"Lemoine et al. 2020","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6971690/"},"watts2006":{"short":"Watts et al. 2006","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajp.20214"},"wilson2001":{"short":"Wilson et al. 2001","url":"https://doi.org/10.1006/anbe.2000.1706"},"massaro2022":{"short":"Massaro et al. 2022","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8977668/"},"wattsMitani2001":{"short":"Watts & Mitani 2001","url":"https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mitani/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2014/08/watts_and_mitani_2001.pdf"},"langergraber2017":{"short":"Langergraber et al. 2017","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5514721/"},"potts2020":{"short":"Potts et al. 2020","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7939021/"},"lemoine2023":{"short":"Lemoine et al. 2023","url":"https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3002350"},"wilson2014":{"short":"Wilson et al. 2014","url":"https://doi.org/10.1038/nature13727"},"mitani2010":{"short":"Mitani et al. 2010","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2010.04.021"},"wood2025":{"short":"Wood et al. 2025","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12664014/"},"sandel2026":{"short":"Sandel et al. 2026","url":"https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1126/science.adz4944"},"sandelWatts2021":{"short":"Sandel & Watts 2021","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8277110/"},"feldblum2018":{"short":"Feldblum et al. 2018","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29566432/"},"mitaniAmsler2003":{"short":"Mitani & Amsler 2003","url":"https://doi.org/10.1163/156853903770238355"},"chapman2018":{"short":"Chapman et al. 2018","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1194839"},"watts2012b":{"short":"WATTS et al. 2012","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajp.21015"},"emeryThompson2020":{"short":"Emery et al. 2020","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7709955/"},"watts2012a":{"short":"WATTS et al. 2012","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajp.21016"},"wrangham1998":{"short":"Wrangham et al. 1998","url":"https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020318102257"},"janmaat2013b":{"short":"Janmaat et al. 2013","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-013-0617-z"},"normand2009":{"short":"Normand et al. 2009","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2762532/"},"ban2014":{"short":"Ban et al. 2014","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-014-0771-y"},"janmaat2013a":{"short":"Janmaat et al. 2013","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2013.09.021"},"janmaat2014":{"short":"Janmaat et al. 2014","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4246305/"},"normandBoesch2009":{"short":"Normand & Boesch 2009","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2009.01.025"},"janmaat2016":{"short":"Janmaat et al. 2016","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajp.22527"},"gilby2015":{"short":"Gilby et al. 2015","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4633842/"},"wattsMitani2002":{"short":"Watts & Mitani 2002","url":"https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mitani/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2014/08/watts_and_mitani_2002.pdf"},"mitaniWatts1999":{"short":"Mitani & Watts 1999","url":"https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mitani/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2014/08/mitani_and_watts_1999.pdf"},"mitaniWatts2001":{"short":"Mitani & Watts 2001","url":"https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mitani/wp-content/uploads/sites/152/2014/08/mitani_and_watts_2001.pdf"},"gilbyWrangham2007":{"short":"Gilby & Wrangham 2007","url":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00265-007-0410-6"},"stanford1994":{"short":"Stanford et al. 1994","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8085613/"},"samuni2018":{"short":"Samuni et al. 2018","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6191705/"},"chapman2023":{"short":"Chapman et al. 2023","url":"https://www.wildsolutions.nl/wp-content/uploads/Chapman_et_al._2023_Primate-populations-at-Ngogo-over-nearly-50-yrs.pdf"},"lwanga2011":{"short":"Lwanga et al. 2011","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21557287/"},"mitani2009":{"short":"Mitani 2009","url":"https://science.umd.edu/faculty/wilkinson/BIOL608W/Mitani2009AnimBehav.pdf"},"langergraber2007":{"short":"Langergraber et al. 2007","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1876525/"},"kaburuNewtonFisher2015":{"short":"Kaburu & Newton-Fisher 2015","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4287234/"},"foerster2015":{"short":"Foerster et al. 2015","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4443498/"},"gilbyWrangham2008":{"short":"Gilby & Wrangham 2008","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-008-0612-6"},"gilby2013":{"short":"Gilby et al. 2013","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3582680/"},"bray2016":{"short":"Bray et al. 2016","url":"https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2016.2071"},"foerster2016":{"short":"Foerster et al. 2016","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5064376/"},"arnoldWhiten2001":{"short":"Arnold & Whiten 2001","url":"https://doi.org/10.1163/156853901316924520"},"kutsukakeCastles2004":{"short":"Kutsukake & Castles 2004","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10329-004-0082-z"},"wittigBoesch2010":{"short":"Wittig & Boesch 2010","url":"https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0013995"},"boesch2006":{"short":"Boesch et al. 2006","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.20341"},"wroblewski2009":{"short":"Wroblewski et al. 2009","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2689943/"},"fraser2008":{"short":"Fraser et al. 2008","url":"https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1439-0310.2008.01527.x"},"lewis2023":{"short":"Lewis et al. 2023","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10756267/"},"wood2017":{"short":"Wood et al. 2017","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5526083/"},"emeryThompson2018":{"short":"Emery et al. 2018","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6170528/"},"williams2008":{"short":"Williams et al. 2008","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajp.20573"},"negrey2019":{"short":"Negrey et al. 2019","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6455141/"},"scully2018":{"short":"Scully et al. 2018","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5782908/"},"fedurek2022":{"short":"Fedurek et al. 2022","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9314064/"},"emeryThompson2007":{"short":"Emery et al. 2007","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2190291/"},"muller2020":{"short":"Muller et al. 2020","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7337577/"},"wood2023":{"short":"Wood et al. 2023","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10645439/"},"walker2018":{"short":"Walker et al. 2018","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5819610/"},"jones2010":{"short":"Jones et al. 2010","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3192870/"},"pusey1997":{"short":"Pusey et al. 1997","url":"https://doi.org/10.1126/science.277.5327.828"},"crockford2020":{"short":"Crockford et al. 2020","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7500924/"},"nakamura2014":{"short":"Nakamura et al. 2014","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.22411"},"mitaniNishida1993":{"short":"Mitani & Nishida 1993","url":"https://doi.org/10.1006/anbe.1993.1088"},"desai2022":{"short":"Desai et al. 2022","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9786991/"},"clarkArcadi2004":{"short":"Clark et al. 2004","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10329-003-0070-8"},"eleuteri2025":{"short":"Eleuteri et al. 2025","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2025.04.019"},"eleuteri2022":{"short":"Eleuteri et al. 2022","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2022.07.013"},"kalanBoesch2015":{"short":"Kalan & Boesch 2015","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-015-1982-1"},"slocombe2010":{"short":"Slocombe et al. 2010","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s00265-010-1006-0"},"clarkWrangham1994":{"short":"Clark & Wrangham 1994","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02735273"},"hobaiterByrne2011":{"short":"Hobaiter & Byrne 2011","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-011-0409-2"},"hobaiterByrne2014":{"short":"Hobaiter & Byrne 2014","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2014.05.066"},"crockford2012":{"short":"Crockford et al. 2012","url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2011.11.053"},"stanton2020":{"short":"Stanton et al. 2020","url":"https://scholars.duke.edu/publication/1431229"},"girardButtoz2021":{"short":"Girard-Buttoz et al. 2021","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8208813/"},"samuni2020":{"short":"Samuni et al. 2020","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6945487/"},"sabbi2021":{"short":"Sabbi et al. 2021","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8000022/"},"hobaiter2014":{"short":"Hobaiter et al. 2014","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4118915/"}},"targets":[{"id":"T-ACT-1","domain":"Activity","metric":"Adult feeding share of daytime","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction of daytime","basis":"spans verified values; the old ~45–55% design target is not supported","field":[{"population":"Budongo Waibira","years":"2016-10 to 2017-06","value":"males 0.36, females 0.37"},{"population":"Kanyawara females","years":"2014-2015","value":"309 ± 85 min/day feeding (≈0.43 of a 12 h day, derived)"}],"sources":["uwimbabazi2019","villioth2025"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.33–0.5","range":{"lo":0.33,"hi":0.5},"note":"","mean":0.4701,"perSeed":[0.4651,0.479,0.4659,0.4743,0.4662],"parts":{"male":0.3779,"female":0.5503},"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.4643}},{"id":"T-ACT-2","domain":"Activity","metric":"Adult travel share of daytime","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"Ngogo control days to Waibira","field":[{"population":"Budongo Waibira","years":"2016-2017","value":"males 0.21, females 0.20"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"2004-2006","value":"0.14 on non-patrol control days (0.58 during patrols)"}],"sources":["amsler2010","villioth2025"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["tuned"],"band":"0.12–0.25","range":{"lo":0.12,"hi":0.25},"note":"","mean":0.2262,"perSeed":[0.2193,0.2187,0.2316,0.2253,0.236],"parts":{"male":0.3049,"female":0.1577},"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.2343}},{"id":"T-ACT-3","domain":"Activity","metric":"Adult grooming share of daytime","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"one site, widened","field":[{"population":"Budongo Waibira","years":"2016-2017","value":"males 0.15, females 0.12"}],"sources":["villioth2025"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"0.08–0.18","range":{"lo":0.08,"hi":0.18},"note":"","mean":0.0842,"perSeed":[0.09249,0.07944,0.08631,0.07725,0.08553],"parts":{"male":0.08489,"female":0.0836},"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.0838}},{"id":"T-ACT-4","domain":"Activity","metric":"Adult resting (including grooming) share of daytime","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"two Kibale sites plus Waibira","field":[{"population":"Ngogo; Kanyawara","years":"2005-2006; 2006","value":"0.340; 0.448 (monthly means, n = 12 months each)"},{"population":"Budongo Waibira","years":"2016-2017","value":"rest + groom ≈ 0.43 (derived)"}],"sources":["potts2011","villioth2025"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.3–0.47","range":{"lo":0.3,"hi":0.47},"note":"","mean":0.2788,"perSeed":[0.2953,0.2807,0.2717,0.2728,0.2737],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.2751}},{"id":"T-ACT-5","domain":"Activity","metric":"Sex and reproductive-state differences in activity","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"male–female feeding difference ≤ 0.05; lactating females travel less than males","field":[{"population":"Budongo Waibira","years":"2016-2017","value":"no category differs by more than 0.03 between sexes"},{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"2002-2003","value":"lactating females travel less than males (p = 0.028); active day 11 h 34 min (M) vs 10 h 57 min (lactating F)"}],"sources":["batesByrne2009","villioth2025"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"male–female feeding difference ≤ 0.05; lactating females travel less than males","range":null,"note":"0/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":-0.1724,"perSeed":[-0.1626,-0.1798,-0.1703,-0.18,-0.1693],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":-0.162}},{"id":"T-PTY-1","domain":"Parties","metric":"Mean party size","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"individuals (22-member community)","basis":"Kanyawara (~45–50 members) scaled down; wide because party size is site-specific","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1992-2006","value":"9.2 ± 7.0 individuals per follow; 3.0 ± 3.0 adult males, 2.3 ± 1.8 adult females"},{"population":"Kanyawara; Ngogo","years":"2005-2006","value":"feeding party 8.39 (1–32); 7.29 (1–40)"}],"sources":["potts2011","wilson2012"],"verdict":"pass","key":"tuned","flags":["tuned"],"band":"3–9","range":{"lo":3,"hi":9},"note":"","mean":3.239,"perSeed":[3.172,3.222,3.315,3.085,3.399],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":3.239}},{"id":"T-PTY-2","domain":"Parties","metric":"Party size vs fruit and patch size","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"weak habitat-fruit effect (R² ≤ 0.1); patch-size effect R² 0.2–0.8","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1999-2003","value":"male party size vs fruit index R² = 0.05 (F1,143 = 6.75, P = 0.01)"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"—","value":"monthly mean party size not correlated with fruit"}],"sources":["mitaniWatts2005","potts2011","wakefield2008"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"weak habitat-fruit effect (R² ≤ 0.1); patch-size effect R² 0.2–0.8","range":null,"note":"0/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":0.0247,"perSeed":[0.03749,0.02294,0.02107,0.02143,0.02056],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.01894}},{"id":"T-PTY-3","domain":"Parties","metric":"More males per party in the periphery","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"periphery parties have ≥ 1.5× the males of core-only parties","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1997-1998","value":"median males 5.9 (periphery-visiting, N = 62) vs 2.2 (core-only, N = 149)"}],"sources":["wilson2007"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"periphery parties have ≥ 1.5× the males of core-only parties","range":null,"note":"1/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":1.314,"perSeed":[1,1.381,1.252,1.904,1.033],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":1.366}},{"id":"T-PTY-4","domain":"Parties","metric":"Female gregariousness","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"L","units":"fraction of female time alone","basis":"abstract-level values; males alone less often","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"—","value":"females with ≥ 1 other female 64% of time; less gregarious than males"},{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"1988","value":"females alone 45% of time"}],"sources":["doran1997","lehmannBoesch2008","wakefield2008"],"verdict":"fail","key":"compromised","flags":["compromised"],"band":"0.15–0.45","range":{"lo":0.15,"hi":0.45},"note":"","mean":0.5151,"perSeed":[0.5536,0.5083,0.4802,0.5378,0.4955],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"compromised","mean":0.5129}},{"id":"T-RNG-1","domain":"Ranging","metric":"Annual home range of a 22-member community","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"km²","basis":"small-to-mid communities; West has 22 members and 7 adult males","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1992-2006","value":"median annual 16.4 km² (10.8–29.5)"},{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"1994-1995","value":"6.78 km² (MCP)"}],"sources":["lemoine2020b","newtonFisher2003","villioth2025"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"5–16","range":{"lo":5,"hi":16},"note":"","mean":1.846,"perSeed":[2.63,1.58,1.38,2.46,1.18],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":2.272}},{"id":"T-RNG-2","domain":"Ranging","metric":"Range size scales with community size","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"km² per weaned individual","basis":"positive slope; mixed evidence for males","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"1997-2016","value":"+0.78 ± 0.17 km² per weaned individual (between groups); +1.10 ± 0.48 km² per added male within a group (p = 0.052)"},{"population":"Gombe","years":"18 y","value":"number of males did not correlate with range size"}],"sources":["lemoine2020b","williams2004"],"verdict":"scale","key":"scale","flags":[],"band":"0.3–1.2","range":{"lo":0.3,"hi":1.2},"note":"not scored: a community-year used 12 (< 20) cells of 500 m, so one cell moves the value (would be inconclusive); would be fail, but the 95% interval over seeds -0.09–0.37 crosses the band edge","mean":0.1364,"perSeed":[0.2141,-0.1352,0.1201,0.375,0.1081],"fresh":{"verdict":"scale","key":"scale","mean":0.1458}},{"id":"T-RNG-3","domain":"Ranging","metric":"Core concentration","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"share of use in densest 36% of area","basis":"Kanyawara","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1996-1998","value":"core 36% of area holds 85% of observation time; periphery 39.9% of area, 11% of time"},{"population":"Taï South (P. t. verus)","years":"2009-2011","value":"50% kernel 6.40 km² = 23% of 95% kernel 27.61 km² (derived)"}],"sources":["jang2019","wilson2007"],"verdict":"scale","key":"scale","flags":[],"band":"0.75–0.9","range":{"lo":0.75,"hi":0.9},"note":"not scored: a community-year used 12 (< 20) cells of 500 m, so one cell moves the value (would be inconclusive); would be pass, but the 95% interval over seeds 0.86–0.92 crosses the band edge","mean":0.8933,"perSeed":[0.8623,0.8867,0.9287,0.8901,0.8989],"fresh":{"verdict":"scale","key":"scale","mean":0.8867}},{"id":"T-RNG-4","domain":"Ranging","metric":"Adult male day range","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"km/day","basis":"also 0.4–0.9 range diameters per day (derived)","field":[{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"2002-2003","value":"males 2.7 ± 1.5 km/day"},{"population":"Taï South (P. t. verus)","years":"2009-2011","value":"females median 4.03 km (1.11–14.16)"}],"sources":["batesByrne2009","jang2019"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["tuned","held as fail"],"band":"1.5–3.5","range":{"lo":1.5,"hi":3.5},"note":"held as fail: the 5-min path is inflated by back-and-forth movement; reported as failed until trajectories are goal-directed (integrator, C7a; parts path30Km, netKm and straightness30) (would be inconclusive); would be fail, but the 95% interval over seeds 3.45–3.63 crosses the band edge","mean":3.541,"perSeed":[3.463,3.602,3.626,3.495,3.519],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":3.594}},{"id":"T-RNG-5","domain":"Ranging","metric":"Lactating female day range relative to males","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"ratio","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"2002-2003","value":"lactating 1.2 ± 0.8, receptive 2.2 ± 0.8, males 2.7 ± 1.5 km"}],"sources":["batesByrne2009"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"0.3–0.6","range":{"lo":0.3,"hi":0.6},"note":"","mean":0.4159,"perSeed":[0.4488,0.3655,0.4082,0.403,0.454],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","mean":0.4533}},{"id":"T-RNG-6","domain":"Ranging","metric":"Range variability over years","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"max/min ratio","basis":"ranges are not static","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1998-2006","value":"annual range 29.5 km² (1998) → 13.8 km² (2006); median 16.4 (10.8–29.5)"}],"sources":["wilson2012"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"1.2–3","range":{"lo":1.2,"hi":3},"note":"needs >= 2 years","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-IGE-1","domain":"Encounters","metric":"Intergroup encounters per community-year","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"per community-year","basis":"Kanyawara and Taï; the simulated communities are small","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1992-2006","value":"120 encounters in 15 y = 8.0 per year (derived); on 1.9% of follows"},{"population":"Taï, 4 groups (P. t. verus)","years":"1997-2016","value":"384 encounters in 54 group-years = 7.1 per year (derived)"}],"sources":["lemoine2020a","watts2006","wilson2012"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"5–12","range":{"lo":5,"hi":12},"note":"","mean":2.591,"perSeed":[1.777,2.716,3.987,3.233,1.242],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":2.445}},{"id":"T-IGE-2","domain":"Encounters","metric":"Share of encounters that are auditory only","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"two sites","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1992-2006","value":"0.85 (102 acoustic, 15 visual, 3 physical)"},{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"1997-2016","value":"0.73 (281 vocal of 384, derived)"}],"sources":["lemoine2020a","wilson2012"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.7–0.9","range":{"lo":0.7,"hi":0.9},"note":"","mean":0.9778,"perSeed":[1,0.8889,1,1,1],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.8733}},{"id":"T-IGE-3","domain":"Encounters","metric":"Approach depends on own males","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"log-odds per male","basis":"±2 SE","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1992-2006","value":"log-odds of approach +0.49 (SE 0.12) per adult male; vocal response +0.34 (SE 0.075); oestrous females lower approach"}],"sources":["wilson2012"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.25–0.75","range":{"lo":0.25,"hi":0.75},"note":"","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":null}},{"id":"T-IGE-4","domain":"Encounters","metric":"Playback response by party composition","role":"fitted","encoded":true,"evidence":"H","units":"pattern","basis":"as reported","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1996-1998","value":"≥ 3 males: approach 12/13, call 12/13; 1–2 males: approach 5/9, call 1/9; female-only: never called"}],"sources":["wilson2001"],"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"as reported","range":null,"note":"","mean":0.1667,"perSeed":[null,0,null,0.3333,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","mean":null}},{"id":"T-IGE-5","domain":"Encounters","metric":"Encounters happen in the periphery","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"range radii","basis":"derived","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1992-2006","value":"median 1,867 m (288–4,406) from centre; equal-area radius of 16.4 km² = 2.28 km → 0.82 R (derived)"}],"sources":["wilson2012"],"verdict":"scale","key":"compromised","flags":["revised post hoc","compromised"],"band":"0.6–1.1","range":{"lo":0.6,"hi":1.1},"note":"not scored: a community-year used 12 (< 20) cells of 500 m, so one cell moves the value (would be inconclusive); would be fail, but the 95% interval over seeds 0.38–0.77 crosses the band edge","mean":0.5767,"perSeed":[0.4563,0.8341,0.6241,0.4672,0.5016],"fresh":{"verdict":"scale","key":"compromised","mean":0.6812}},{"id":"T-PAT-1","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Patrol rate in small communities","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"per week","basis":"Gombe/Taï scale; Ngogo is a 25-male community","field":[{"population":"Gombe Kasekela; Taï North","years":"1977-1982; —","value":"0.30 and 0.3 per week"},{"population":"Gombe","years":"1978-2007","value":"180 patrols in 30 y; annual median 4.5 (0–19)"}],"sources":["massaro2022","wattsMitani2001"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["revised post hoc","tuned"],"band":"0.1–0.5","range":{"lo":0.1,"hi":0.5},"note":"","mean":0.02813,"perSeed":[0.03196,0.03836,0.04475,0.006393,0.01918],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.01406}},{"id":"T-PAT-2","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Per-male patrol participation","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"patrols per male-year","basis":"similar across sites","field":[{"population":"Ngogo; Taï; Gombe","years":"1996-2015","value":"14.2; ~10; 14.4 patrols per male per year"}],"sources":["langergraber2017"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"7–18","range":{"lo":7,"hi":18},"note":"","mean":1.06,"perSeed":[1.071,1.571,1.643,0.2143,0.8],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.4692}},{"id":"T-PAT-3","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Patrol composition","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"share of males (≤ 10-male communities)","basis":"Gombe, Taï","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"1978-2007","value":"74.5 ± 11.1% of males per patrol; median 8 males (1–13)"},{"population":"Taï; Ngogo","years":"—; 1998-1999","value":"Taï 72% of males, females on 57% of patrols; Ngogo 9.4 adult males (3–19), females essentially absent"}],"sources":["langergraber2017","massaro2022","wattsMitani2001"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"0.55–0.85","range":{"lo":0.55,"hi":0.85},"note":"","mean":0.7488,"perSeed":[0.7,0.8571,0.6514,0.75,0.7857],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","mean":0.6865}},{"id":"T-PAT-4","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Patrol predictors","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"positive male and fruit effects; no oestrous effect","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1999-2003","value":"+17% odds per extra male; fruit index 812 vs 642 on patrol vs other days (+0.10% odds per unit); oestrous females and intruder pressure no effect"}],"sources":["mitaniWatts2005"],"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","flags":[],"band":"positive male and fruit effects; no oestrous effect","range":null,"note":"","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","mean":null}},{"id":"T-PAT-5","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Patrol duration and distance","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"min (distance 1–4 km)","basis":"±1 SD","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"2004-2006","value":"134 min (15–348, SD 88); 2,456 m (SD 1,492); travel 58% of patrol time"}],"sources":["amsler2010"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"60–240","range":{"lo":60,"hi":240},"note":"","mean":145.8,"perSeed":[141.2,151.5,143.7,152,140.7],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","mean":129}},{"id":"T-PAT-6","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Incursion share","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1999-2003","value":"0.58 (42/72)"}],"sources":["mitaniWatts2005"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.4–0.7","range":{"lo":0.4,"hi":0.7},"note":"","mean":0.1922,"perSeed":[0.1111,0.1,0.3,0.2,0.25],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.2212}},{"id":"T-PAT-7","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Patrol contact and violence","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"contact fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1997-2003","value":"contact 30/95 (0.32); physical aggression 12/95 (0.13); attacks in 40% of patrols with contact"}],"sources":["watts2006"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.15–0.45","range":{"lo":0.15,"hi":0.45},"note":"","mean":0.03333,"perSeed":[0,0.1667,0,0,0],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.08333}},{"id":"T-PAT-8","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Patrols and fruit","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"Spearman rho","basis":"bootstrap 90% CI over months (docs/realism-design.md §5.3.1 P5 rule), computed before any run of the corrected model","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-2015","value":"rho 0.059 (90% bootstrap over months -0.057 to 0.170); 279 patrols in 211 months, 113 months without a patrol; mean 1.30 patrols per 30 d"}],"sources":["langergraber2017","potts2020","mitaniWatts2005"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscorable","flags":["not scorable"],"band":"-0.057–0.17","range":{"lo":-0.057,"hi":0.17},"note":"not scorable: real record lacks observation effort; instrument limitation found before any simulated value existed (integrator ruling 2026-09-29). Returns if monthly observation days are obtained (Mitani/Watts data request)","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-BRD-1","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Advance after border stops","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"log-odds per adult present","basis":"cluster-bootstrap 90% CI (docs/realism-design.md §5.3.1 P5 rule), computed before any run of the corrected model; the share part (band 0.411-0.486) is partly encoded through patrolIncursionP (fitted to T-PAT-6) and is reported, not scored","field":[{"population":"Taï East and South (P. t. verus)","years":"2013-2016","value":"advance share 0.448 (90% 0.411-0.486); slope +0.072 log-odds per adult present (90% 0.037-0.107); not scored: slope on the imbalance of power (own - rival adults) +0.044 (90% 0.016-0.072)"}],"sources":["lemoine2023"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"0.037–0.107","range":{"lo":0.037,"hi":0.107},"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-PAT-9","domain":"Patrols","metric":"Patrol sector concentration (check)","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"share of community-years","basis":"pattern (Amendment A); encoded-descriptive check, never counted as validation","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-1999","value":"repeat patrols on contested edges; months without patrols elsewhere"}],"sources":["wattsMitani2001"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"0.5–1","range":{"lo":0.5,"hi":1},"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-LET-1","domain":"Killings","metric":"Killings per community-year","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"per community-year","basis":"median community to pooled rate; Ngogo is an outlier","field":[{"population":"18 communities, 12 eastern","years":"various; 426 community-years","value":"pooled observed + inferred 0.23; incl. suspected 0.36; median across communities ≈ 0.08 (derived from Fig. 1); Kanyawara ≈ 0.08; Ngogo ≈ 1.67"}],"sources":["wilson2014"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.02–0.36","range":{"lo":0.02,"hi":0.36},"note":"0 events; 95% interval 0.00–0.24 overlaps the band","mean":0,"perSeed":[0,0,0,0,0],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0}},{"id":"T-LET-2","domain":"Killings","metric":"Victim composition","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"male share","basis":"compilation","field":[{"population":"18 communities","years":"various","value":"73% of victims male; 66% of killings intercommunity; males and infants at highest risk"}],"sources":["wilson2014"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"0.6–0.85","range":{"lo":0.6,"hi":0.85},"note":"no killings","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-LET-3","domain":"Killings","metric":"Numerical odds in lethal attacks","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"H","units":"attacker/defender ratio (median)","basis":"compilation","field":[{"population":"18 communities","years":"various","value":"median 9 attacking males (2–28) vs median 0 defending males; attackers outnumber defenders by a median factor of 8 (1–32)"}],"sources":["wilson2014"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"4–16","range":{"lo":4,"hi":16},"note":"no killings","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-LET-4","domain":"Killings","metric":"Territorial expansion after killings (scenario)","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"proportional range gain","basis":"direction toward where killings occurred","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1999-2009","value":"+6.4 km² (+22.3%) after 21 killings (18 observed, 3 inferred) in 10 y; 13 of 21 in the NE, where the expansion happened; NE used on 32.6% of days after June 2009"}],"sources":["mitani2010"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"0.1–0.35","range":{"lo":0.1,"hi":0.35},"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: ranges are fixed circles that relax back after a killing; living territories and the expansion scenario arrive in C6)","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-LET-5","domain":"Killings","metric":"Payoff of expansion (scenario)","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"higher fertility and infant survival after expansion","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"3 y before vs after the 2009 expansion","value":"births 15 → 37 (RR 2.75, 95% CI 1.4–5.2); infant death before age 3: 41% → 8%"}],"sources":["wood2025"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"higher fertility and infant survival after expansion","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no expansion scenario or territory-dependent fertility (C6, C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-LET-6","domain":"Killings","metric":"Killings happen on patrols","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1999-2008","value":"17 of 18 observed killings by males on patrol"}],"sources":["mitani2010"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"0.6–1","range":{"lo":0.6,"hi":1},"note":"no observed killings","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-FIS-1","domain":"Fission","metric":"Fission is rare and needs a large community","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"no fission below ~10 adult males; ≤ 1 per 100 community-years in 20–40-male communities","field":[{"population":"Gombe; Ngogo","years":"1973; 2015-2018","value":"the only two permanent fissions observed; Ngogo had ~200 members and > 30 adult males by 2015"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-2022","value":"network polarized in 2015; two distinct groups by 2018"}],"sources":["sandel2026","sandelWatts2021"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"no fission below ~10 adult males; ≤ 1 per 100 community-years in 20–40-male communities","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: communities cannot split (fission is stage C9))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-FIS-2","domain":"Fission","metric":"Fission antecedents","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"years of rising modularity","basis":"Gombe and Ngogo; subgroups can persist without splitting","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"1967-1973","value":"subgrouping in grooming and association networks rose sharply in 1971–72; split 1973; coincided with a struggle among 3 top males and high male:female ratio"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"2003","value":"two stable male subgroups with overlapping ranges and no split"}],"sources":["feldblum2018","mitaniAmsler2003"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"1–3","range":{"lo":1,"hi":3},"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: communities cannot split (C9))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-FIS-3","domain":"Fission","metric":"Lethal violence after fission","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"post-split rate ÷ baseline rate","basis":"both cases far above T-LET-1","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"1974-1977","value":"≥ 4 (probably 5) adult males and 1 adult female of Kahama killed by Kasekela over ~4 y"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"2018-2025","value":"24 attacks; ≥ 7 mature males and 17 infants of the Central group killed by the West group"}],"sources":["sandel2026","sandelWatts2021"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"≥ 5","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: communities cannot split (C9))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-FIS-4","domain":"Fission","metric":"Former associates become victims","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"bonds do not protect after fission","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-2019","value":"victim (name withheld) had 12.5–24.8% yearly party association with western males; last coalitions with attackers in 2011–12"}],"sources":["sandelWatts2021"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"bonds do not protect after fission","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: communities cannot split (C9))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-FIS-5","domain":"Fission","metric":"Patrols after a fission","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"ratio","basis":"bootstrap 90% CI over years (C9 pre-registration rule), computed before any C9 run","field":[{"population":"Ngogo West and Central","years":"2017-2022","value":"median ratio 7.35 (yearly 5.3-15.3); West (7-11 adult males) 5.6-40 patrols per 10 males per year, Central (23-26) 0.8-4"}],"sources":["sandel2026"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"6.1905–11.4069","range":{"lo":6.1905,"hi":11.4069},"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-FOOD-1","domain":"Food","metric":"Phenology index","role":"fitted","encoded":true,"evidence":"H","units":"mean share of stems","basis":"monthly CV 0.35–0.55; between-year CV 0.15–0.35","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-2017","value":"mean 8.7% (SD 4.1), range 0.7–20.3%"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1998-2013","value":"mean 8.41% (SD 4.40), monthly CV 0.52, between-year CV 0.25 (computed from data)"}],"sources":["chapman2018","potts2020","watts2012b"],"verdict":"pass","key":"encoded","flags":[],"band":"0.06–0.11","range":{"lo":0.06,"hi":0.11},"note":"","mean":0.08991,"perSeed":[0.08803,0.08248,0.09359,0.07778,0.1077],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"encoded","mean":0.09513}},{"id":"T-FOOD-2","domain":"Food","metric":"Fruit share of feeding time","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"two Kibale sites","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-2010","value":"all fruit 72.1% (SD 12.5; monthly 36.2–94.1); figs 26.2%; leaves 19.4%; pith 2.5%"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1994-2018","value":"fruit 64.0% (annual 50.0–74.1); leaves 11.2%"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2020","watts2012a"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"0.6–0.78","range":{"lo":0.6,"hi":0.78},"note":"","mean":0.7525,"perSeed":[0.7733,0.7223,0.771,0.7382,0.7575],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.7702}},{"id":"T-FOOD-3","domain":"Food","metric":"Fallback switching","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"Pearson r (fruit share vs phenology index)","basis":"design threshold; positive, site-specific fallback type","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-2009","value":"fallback: leaves (mainly Pterygota saplings, 8.5% of feeding); pith not a fallback; figs a staple"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1990s","value":"pith is the fallback"}],"sources":["potts2011","watts2012b","wrangham1998"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":[],"band":"≥ 0.3","range":null,"note":"would be fail, but the 95% interval over seeds -0.48–0.68 crosses the band edge","mean":0.1008,"perSeed":[-0.1488,0.5835,-0.3238,0.6366,-0.2437],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.2935}},{"id":"T-FOOD-4","domain":"Food","metric":"Feeding trees visited per day","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"trees/day","basis":"Taï only; no Kibale value found","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2009-2011","value":"7.14 trees/day (1–21); inspections 4.97/day"},{"population":"Taï","years":"2006-2007","value":"two females: 14.0 and 18.1 trees/day over 28 days"}],"sources":["janmaat2013b","normand2009"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"4–15","range":{"lo":4,"hi":15},"note":"","mean":4.65,"perSeed":[4.79,4.441,4.891,4.374,4.754],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","mean":4.749}},{"id":"T-FOOD-5","domain":"Food","metric":"Nearest-tree choice share","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"greedy search would give ≈ 1","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2006-2007","value":"nearest productive tree chosen only 30% of the time"}],"sources":["normand2009"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.15–0.45","range":{"lo":0.15,"hi":0.45},"note":"","mean":0.1172,"perSeed":[0.1159,0.1179,0.1191,0.1254,0.1074],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.1123}},{"id":"T-FOOD-6","domain":"Food","metric":"Revisit interval","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"days","basis":"Taï","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2006-2007","value":"5.37 days"},{"population":"Taï","years":"2009-2011","value":"2.5 days (max 26)"}],"sources":["ban2014","normand2009"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"2–7","range":{"lo":2,"hi":7},"note":"","mean":16.99,"perSeed":[19.82,15.43,15.6,15.91,18.21],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":17.82}},{"id":"T-FOOD-7","domain":"Food","metric":"Out-of-sight approach distance","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"m (median)","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2009-2011","value":"mean 537.5 m (SD 499; 6.5–2,842 m), about 80 min"}],"sources":["ban2014"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":[],"band":"300–800","range":{"lo":300,"hi":800},"note":"would be fail, but the 95% interval over seeds 283.54–312.98 crosses the band edge","mean":298.3,"perSeed":[285.9,310.9,297.3,309.7,287.5],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":301}},{"id":"T-FOOD-8","domain":"Food","metric":"Goal-directed inspections","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2009-2011","value":"13% of inspections goal-directed (more for large crowns); empty-tree inspections rise after the first fruit of that species and track its synchrony"}],"sources":["janmaat2013a"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"0.05–0.25","range":{"lo":0.05,"hi":0.25},"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no species phenology beliefs or inspection behaviour (C7))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-FOOD-9","domain":"Food","metric":"Approach kinematics","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"slow near goal; faster to figs","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2006-2007","value":"significant slowing before reaching the resource"},{"population":"Taï","years":"—","value":"approach speed to figs 0.33 m/s vs 0.16 m/s for other fruit"}],"sources":["janmaat2014","normandBoesch2009"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"slow near goal; faster to figs","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: movement speed does not change near a goal (C7 approach kinematics))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-FOOD-10","domain":"Food","metric":"Breakfast planning","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"—","value":"18% of departures before sunrise; nested in the breakfast tree only 2%"}],"sources":["janmaat2014"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.08–0.3","range":{"lo":0.08,"hi":0.3},"note":"","mean":0.5175,"perSeed":[0.5315,0.4995,0.5133,0.5146,0.5288],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.5289}},{"id":"T-FOOD-11","domain":"Food","metric":"Fruiting food trees encountered along travel","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"m per fruiting tree (annual mean)","basis":"patch density × phenology check","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1990-2011","value":"one fruiting food tree per 97 m (worst month one per 1,730 m); a large crop every 21 km"}],"sources":["janmaat2016"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":["tuned"],"band":"60–160","range":{"lo":60,"hi":160},"note":"would be fail, but the 95% interval over seeds 142.13–259.62 crosses the band edge","mean":200.9,"perSeed":[169,247.5,200.8,246.8,140.3],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":213}},{"id":"T-HUN-1","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Hunts per community-year","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"per community-year (3–7 males)","basis":"Kanyawara scaled","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara (11.4 males)","years":"1996-2014","value":"194 hunts in 224 months ≈ 10.4 per year (derived)"},{"population":"Ngogo (~24 males)","years":"1995-1999","value":"45.1 successful hunts per year (55.2 in 1998–99)"}],"sources":["gilby2015","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"5–25","range":{"lo":5,"hi":25},"note":"","mean":0.8,"perSeed":[1,1.333,0.3333,1,0.3333],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.8667}},{"id":"T-HUN-2","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Hunt success","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"four communities","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara; Kasekela; Mitumba","years":"1996-2014; 1976-2013; 2000-2014","value":"0.613; 0.623; 0.532"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-1998","value":"0.73 (36/49); red colobus 0.78 (32/41)"}],"sources":["gilby2015","mitaniWatts1999","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.5–0.8","range":{"lo":0.5,"hi":0.8},"note":"","mean":0.1667,"perSeed":[0.3333,0.5,0,0,0],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.3167}},{"id":"T-HUN-3","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Hunting probability per colobus encounter","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"Kibale sites; Gombe differs","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara; Kasekela; Mitumba","years":"as above","value":"0.079; 0.647; 0.480"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-1999","value":"0.37 (61/164)"}],"sources":["gilby2015","mitaniWatts2001"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.05–0.4","range":{"lo":0.05,"hi":0.4},"note":"","mean":0.0009542,"perSeed":[0.00291,0.0009597,0.0009017,0,0],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.001984}},{"id":"T-HUN-4","domain":"Hunting","metric":"More males, more hunting","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"odds ratio per male","basis":"positive at every site","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara; Kasekela; Mitumba","years":"as above","value":"+48%; +8%; +72% odds per male"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-1999","value":"parties with ≤ 5 males hunted red colobus 3 times (1 success); every hunt with ≥ 20 males succeeded"}],"sources":["gilby2015","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":[],"band":"1.05–1.8","range":{"lo":1.05,"hi":1.8},"note":"would be fail, but the 95% interval over seeds 0.46–4.46 crosses the band edge","mean":2.46,"perSeed":[3.259,2.472,1.65,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":2.047}},{"id":"T-HUN-5","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Hunting tracks fruit","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"r² (positive slope)","basis":"two Kibale sites","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-1999","value":"hunts per day vs ripe fruit r² = 0.38 (16 months)"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-1999","value":"hunts per month vs ripe fruit r² = 0.37; rainfall no effect"}],"sources":["gilbyWrangham2007","mitaniWatts2001","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"≥ 0.1","range":null,"note":"0/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":0.06619,"perSeed":[0.1253,0.004174,0.05392,0.1094,0.0381],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.08958}},{"id":"T-HUN-6","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Hunting comes in bursts","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"dispersion index","basis":"clustering, not Poisson","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"Oct-Dec 1998","value":"57-day binge: 17 red colobus hunts (15 successful), 69 killed, during a Uvariopsis crop"},{"population":"Gombe","years":"1982-1991","value":"strong binge tendency; peak Aug–Sep, low Apr–May"}],"sources":["stanford1994","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"≥ 1.5","range":null,"note":"","mean":1,"perSeed":[1,1,null,1,1],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":1}},{"id":"T-HUN-7","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Kills per successful hunt","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"prey per success (3–7 males)","basis":"small-to-mid communities","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara; Kasekela; Mitumba","years":"as above","value":"1.28; 1.90; 1.30"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-1998","value":"3.41 ± 1.79"}],"sources":["gilby2015","mitaniWatts1999"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"1.2–2","range":{"lo":1.2,"hi":2},"note":"","mean":1,"perSeed":[1,1,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":1}},{"id":"T-HUN-8","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Adult males make most kills","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"two sites","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-1998","value":"0.86 (n = 90 kills)"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-1999","value":"0.90 (235/261)"}],"sources":["mitaniWatts1999","stanford1994","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.8–0.95","range":{"lo":0.8,"hi":0.95},"note":"","mean":0.75,"perSeed":[1,0.5,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":1}},{"id":"T-HUN-9","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Meat sharing","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"about half of those present eat; bond partners favoured ~1.8×","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-1999","value":"15.2 adult males present, 8.7 ate meat; 12.1 individuals ate per hunt"},{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2013-2015","value":"owners shared with 48% of adults present; with 62% of bond partners vs 35% of others"}],"sources":["samuni2018","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"about half of those present eat; bond partners favoured ~1.8×","range":null,"note":"0/1 seeds show the pattern","mean":0.2222,"perSeed":[null,0.2222,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-HUN-10","domain":"Hunting","metric":"Prey decline under heavy predation (scenario)","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"decline under 6–12%/y offtake; persistence under low offtake","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1975-2008","value":"red colobus down about 89% on one transect"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1975-2021","value":"encounters fell (r = −0.903 over 47 y); no recovery"}],"sources":["chapman2023","lwanga2011","wattsMitani2002"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"decline under 6–12%/y offtake; persistence under low offtake","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: prey groups have no demography (C7))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-SOC-1","domain":"Social life","metric":"Male bond persistence","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"years (mean longest bond)","basis":"one large sample","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-2007","value":"longest bond per male 7.1 ± 2.0 y; bonds last 1–10 y (mean 1.8 ± 0.7); 7/28 bonded their whole observed span; bonds in year t predict t+1"}],"sources":["mitani2009"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"4–10","range":{"lo":4,"hi":10},"note":"needs >= 2 years (10-year runs in the design)","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-SOC-2","domain":"Social life","metric":"Bonds are mostly with non-kin","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1998-2007","value":"22 of 28 males formed their longest bond with a non-relative"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"—","value":"males prefer maternal brothers, but most affiliative dyads are unrelated"}],"sources":["langergraber2007","mitani2009"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"0.55–0.9","range":{"lo":0.55,"hi":0.9},"note":"","mean":0.7588,"perSeed":[0.7143,0.7143,0.8462,0.7857,0.7333],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.883}},{"id":"T-SOC-3","domain":"Social life","metric":"Grooming reciprocity","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"slope","basis":"two sites","field":[{"population":"Budongo Sonso; Mahale M","years":"2003-2004; 2011","value":"β = 0.655 ± 0.079; 0.721 ± 0.083 (stable), 0.515 ± 0.134 (unstable)"}],"sources":["kaburuNewtonFisher2015"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.45–0.8","range":{"lo":0.45,"hi":0.8},"note":"","mean":0.9341,"perSeed":[0.9634,0.9595,0.9625,0.8352,0.9497],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.9567}},{"id":"T-SOC-4","domain":"Social life","metric":"Association by sex","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"female mean HWI; male > female","basis":"Gombe value; Kanyawara direction","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"10 y","value":"male–male association stronger than female–female; preferences stable over 10 y"},{"population":"Gombe","years":"1974-2011","value":"female mean HWI 0.19 ± 0.07 (0–0.94); mother–daughter 0.63 ± 0.18; sisters 0.43"}],"sources":["foerster2015","gilbyWrangham2008"],"verdict":"pass","key":"compromised","flags":["compromised"],"band":"0.1–0.3","range":{"lo":0.1,"hi":0.3},"note":"5/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":0.1302,"perSeed":[0.1107,0.1251,0.1437,0.1199,0.1518],"parts":{"male":0.2339,"female":0.1302},"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"compromised","mean":0.1358}},{"id":"T-SOC-5","domain":"Social life","metric":"Male hierarchy steepness","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"steepness","basis":"multi-site","field":[{"population":"Multiple sites","years":"various","value":"mean 0.40 ± 0.16; steepness falls with number of males aged 20–30 (r = −0.743)"}],"sources":["kaburuNewtonFisher2015"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.2–0.7","range":{"lo":0.2,"hi":0.7},"note":"would be pass, but the 95% interval over seeds 0.60–0.77 crosses the band edge","mean":0.6861,"perSeed":[0.6505,0.7085,0.6728,0.7941,0.6046],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.6697}},{"id":"T-SOC-6","domain":"Social life","metric":"Pant-grunts concentrate on top males","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"1995-2008","value":"top 3 males received > 75% of pant-grunts"}],"sources":["gilby2013"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"0.6–0.9","range":{"lo":0.6,"hi":0.9},"note":"","mean":0.6324,"perSeed":[0.6288,0.6331,0.6207,0.6173,0.6624],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","mean":0.6481}},{"id":"T-SOC-7","domain":"Social life","metric":"Alpha tenure","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"years","basis":"crude average","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"36 y","value":"8 alpha tenures in 36 y (≈ 4.5 y mean, derived)"}],"sources":["bray2016"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"3–7","range":{"lo":3,"hi":7},"note":"no alpha change in 15 community-years (tenure not estimable; consistent with multi-year tenures)","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":3}},{"id":"T-SOC-8","domain":"Social life","metric":"Females queue","role":"fitted","encoded":true,"evidence":"H","units":"pattern","basis":"as reported","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"1969-2013","value":"best model: no reversals after entry; ~10% of contests against rank without lasting reversal; queue-jumping at 69% of entries"}],"sources":["foerster2016"],"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"as reported","range":null,"note":"0/4 seeds show the pattern","mean":0,"perSeed":[0,0,0,0,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","mean":0}},{"id":"T-SOC-9","domain":"Social life","metric":"Reconciliation","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"Mahale; the existing \"14–22%\" band was not verified","field":[{"population":"Mahale M","years":"—","value":"mean individual corrected conciliatory tendency 14.4%"},{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"—","value":"much less reconciliation than in captivity; compatibility predicts it"}],"sources":["arnoldWhiten2001","kutsukakeCastles2004"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.08–0.22","range":{"lo":0.08,"hi":0.22},"note":"would be pass, but the 95% interval over seeds 0.03–0.15 crosses the band edge","mean":0.09355,"perSeed":[0.1019,0.01455,0.09871,0.1022,0.1505],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.06498}},{"id":"T-SOC-10","domain":"Social life","metric":"Third-party post-conflict affiliation","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"1996-1999","value":"164/876 (18.7%, likely underestimated); 26 to victim vs 83 to aggressor of 109"}],"sources":["wittigBoesch2010"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.1–0.3","range":{"lo":0.1,"hi":0.3},"note":"","mean":0.1807,"perSeed":[0.2187,0.1509,0.1752,0.1637,0.1948],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","mean":0.2096}},{"id":"T-SOC-11","domain":"Social life","metric":"Alpha paternity share","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"two sites","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"22 y","value":"alpha sired 30.3% (36.8% predicted)"},{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"1987-2000","value":"alpha sired 50% (67% with few competitors, 38% with ≥ 4)"}],"sources":["boesch2006","wroblewski2009"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":[],"band":"0.25–0.55","range":{"lo":0.25,"hi":0.55},"note":"would be pass, but the 95% interval over seeds 0.18–0.58 crosses the band edge","mean":0.38,"perSeed":[0.2,0.5,0.5,0.2,0.5],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":0.2467}},{"id":"T-SOC-12","domain":"Social life","metric":"Relationship-quality components","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"L","units":"pattern","basis":"captive; qualitative","field":[{"population":"Captive chimpanzees","years":"—","value":"three components as described"}],"sources":["fraser2008"],"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","flags":[],"band":"captive; qualitative","range":null,"note":"5/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":14.02,"perSeed":[14.19,14.99,10.84,16.33,13.73],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"pass","mean":13.3}},{"id":"T-SOC-13","domain":"Social life","metric":"Long-term recognition","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"years a former partner stays in memory digests","basis":"structural requirement for O11","field":[{"population":"Captive chimpanzees and bonobos","years":"—","value":"looked 0.244 ± 0.072 s longer at former groupmates; no effect of time apart (non-kin up to 9.54 y); a bonobo recognized kin after > 26 y"}],"sources":["lewis2023"],"verdict":"structural","key":"structural","flags":[],"band":"≥ 26","range":null,"note":"a former partner stays in yearly memory digests; covered by tests/sim-relations.test.ts, not an observer metric","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"structural","key":"structural","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-1","domain":"Life and death","metric":"First-year mortality","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"probability","basis":"Ngogo ± site spread","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-2016","value":"0.15 (F 0.17, M 0.12)"},{"population":"Kanyawara; Gombe; Taï","years":"various","value":"0.11; 0.18; 0.08"}],"sources":["wood2017"],"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.11–0.19","range":{"lo":0.11,"hi":0.19},"note":"95% interval 0.12–0.69 overlaps the band","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"inconclusive","key":"inconclusive","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-2","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Life expectancy at 15","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"years","basis":"F 31–39, M 18–24 (±~3 y)","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-2016","value":"F 35.1, M 20.98 y"}],"sources":["wood2017"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"female 31–39, male 18–24","range":null,"note":"only 3 adult deaths (natural-aging demography needs decades; design C8: 40 years × 5 seeds)","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-3","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Survival to 45","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"probability (both sexes)","basis":"tests the adult hazard shape","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-2016","value":"0.35 (F 0.51, M 0.20)"}],"sources":["wood2017"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"0.25–0.45","range":{"lo":0.25,"hi":0.45},"note":"only 8 deaths","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-4","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Causes of death","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fractions","basis":"disease 0.25–0.6, aggression 0.1–0.25","field":[{"population":"Gombe Kasekela","years":"1960-2006","value":"illness 58%, aggression 20% of 86 known-cause deaths; half of illness deaths in epidemics"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1987-2017","value":"respiratory illness 27% of all deaths"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2018","williams2008"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"disease 0.25–0.6, aggression 0.1–0.25","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no disease or snare mortality; causes are not separated from the fitted all-cause hazard (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-5","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Epidemic frequency","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"per community-year","basis":"two sites","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1987-2017","value":"3 epidemics (2001, 2006–07, 2013)"},{"population":"Gombe","years":"1966-2000","value":"5 epidemics (1966, 1968, 1987, 1997, 2000)"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2018","williams2008"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"0.07–0.15","range":{"lo":0.07,"hi":0.15},"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no epidemics (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-6","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Outbreak attack rate and mortality","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"fractions","basis":"attack 0.4–0.9; mortality 0–0.17 (median ~0.08)","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"2016-2017","value":"MPV: 43.8% ill, 25 died (12.2%); R0 1.27"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"2016-2017","value":"HRV3: 69.1% ill, 0 died; R0 1.48"}],"sources":["negrey2019","scully2018","williams2008"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"attack 0.4–0.9; mortality 0–0.17 (median ~0.08)","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no epidemics (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-7","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Who dies in epidemics","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"infants and older adults at higher risk","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"2016-2017","value":"infants OR 5.01 (1.53–19.56); ≥ 30 y OR 3.86 (1.16–15.15)"}],"sources":["negrey2019"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"infants and older adults at higher risk","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no epidemics (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-8","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Respiratory death rate","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"per 1,000 chimp-years","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1995-2016","value":"11.6 per 1,000 chimp-years"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2018"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"5–20","range":{"lo":5,"hi":20},"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no respiratory disease (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-9","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Snare injury prevalence","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"fraction","basis":"Kibale range","field":[{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-2016","value":"~10% of chimps > 3 y"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"—","value":"~29% (Wrangham & Mugume 2000, cited in Wood et al. 2017); about 1 in 3 (cited in Emery Thompson et al. 2020)"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2020","fedurek2022","wood2017"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"0.1–0.3","range":{"lo":0.1,"hi":0.3},"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no snares (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-10","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Age-specific fertility","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"peak births per female-year (at 20–30 y)","basis":"Kanyawara–Gombe; none after ~50–55","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara; Gombe","years":"various","value":"peak 0.197 births/y at 23.6 y; 0.145 at 23.3 y"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-2016","value":"fertility falls after ~30; no births after 50; post-reproductive representation 0.195"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2007","muller2020","wood2023"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.15–0.25","range":{"lo":0.15,"hi":0.25},"note":"","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-11","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Age at first birth","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"years","basis":"Gombe; Kibale consistent","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"—","value":"14.9 y (11.1–22.1)"},{"population":"Kibale","years":"various","value":"youngest mother 14.1 y"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2007","walker2018"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"13.5–16","range":{"lo":13.5,"hi":16},"note":"fewer than 3 first births","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-12","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Birth interval after a surviving infant","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"years","basis":"Kibale values","field":[{"population":"Kibale","years":"various","value":"79.1 months (6.6 y)"},{"population":"Ngogo","years":"1995-2016","value":"5.5 y (SD 1.2)"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2007","emeryThompson2020","wood2023"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"4.8–6.6","range":{"lo":4.8,"hi":6.6},"note":"fewer than 3 intervals (needs multi-year runs)","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-13","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Birth interval after infant death","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"years","basis":"tests cycle resumption and conception per cycle","field":[{"population":"Kibale; all sites","years":"various","value":"29.6 months; 26.6 months"}],"sources":["emeryThompson2007"],"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","flags":[],"band":"1.8–2.6","range":{"lo":1.8,"hi":2.6},"note":"fewer than 3 intervals (needs multi-year runs)","mean":null,"perSeed":[null,null,null,null,null],"fresh":{"verdict":"insufficient","key":"insufficient","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-14","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Female rank and fertility","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"rank advantage in interval and infant survival; magnitude uncertain","field":[{"population":"Gombe","years":"—","value":"birth hazard of non-high-ranking females 0.155× that of high-ranking (P = 0.001)"},{"population":"Gombe","years":"35 y","value":"high-ranking females: higher infant survival, faster-maturing daughters, shorter intervals"}],"sources":["jones2010","pusey1997"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"rank advantage in interval and infant survival; magnitude uncertain","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no path from female rank to fertility or infant survival (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-DEM-15","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Maternal loss after weaning","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"orphaned sons later and less successful","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"—","value":"first paternity 16.3 ± 2.0 vs 12.9 ± 1.6 y; 0.08 vs 0.20 offspring per opportunity"},{"population":"Mahale","years":"—","value":"orphaned males die young even after weaning"}],"sources":["crockford2020","nakamura2014"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"orphaned sons later and less successful","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no post-weaning maternal effects on sons (C8))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-COM-1","domain":"Communication","metric":"Male pant-hoot rate","role":"fitted","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"per male-hour","basis":"two sites","field":[{"population":"Mahale M","years":"1990","value":"0.88–2.36 per hour, mean 1.40 (computed)"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1997-1998","value":"core areas: median 0.76/h (0.14–1.7)"}],"sources":["mitaniNishida1993","wilson2007"],"verdict":"pass","key":"encoded","flags":[],"band":"0.5–1.5","range":{"lo":0.5,"hi":1.5},"note":"","mean":1.019,"perSeed":[1.004,1.018,1.005,1.08,0.9905],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"encoded","mean":1.026}},{"id":"T-COM-2","domain":"Communication","metric":"High-ranking males call more","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"rate falls with rank number","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1997-1998","value":"τ = −0.545 (N = 12); the alpha called 1.5/h in the core and 5.8/h at the periphery"},{"population":"Mahale M","years":"1990","value":"τ = −0.714 (N = 7)"}],"sources":["mitaniNishida1993","wilson2007"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"rate falls with rank number","range":null,"note":"0/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":0.2884,"perSeed":[0.1281,0.4543,0.5707,0.198,0.09108],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.219}},{"id":"T-COM-3","domain":"Communication","metric":"Quiet at the edges","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"periphery rate below core rate","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1997-1998","value":"male focal median 0.76/h core, 0.19/h periphery, 0.0 at crop edges; calls rise with males in party (coefficient 0.33)"}],"sources":["wilson2007"],"verdict":"pass","key":"encoded","flags":[],"band":"periphery rate below core rate","range":null,"note":"5/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":-0.06359,"perSeed":[-0.1312,-0.09236,-0.01453,-0.07589,-0.003929],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","mean":-0.01126}},{"id":"T-COM-4","domain":"Communication","metric":"Calling context","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"travel most common; fruit > herbs","field":[{"population":"Mahale M","years":"1990","value":"before calling: travel 43%, feeding 22%, rest 19%, other 16% (computed)"},{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"1997-1998","value":"core: 0.42/h while feeding on fruit vs 0.0 on herbs"}],"sources":["mitaniNishida1993","wilson2007"],"verdict":"pass","key":"encoded","flags":[],"band":"travel most common; fruit > herbs","range":null,"note":"5/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":0.5704,"perSeed":[0.5638,0.5624,0.583,0.5413,0.6016],"fresh":{"verdict":"pass","key":"encoded","mean":0.5853}},{"id":"T-COM-5","domain":"Communication","metric":"Pant-hoot caller identity is moderately distinctive","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"accuracy ÷ chance","basis":"individual signal is real but noisy","field":[{"population":"Gombe + Kanyawara","years":"2010-2017","value":"19.5% vs 6.9% chance (18 individuals, structural features); 35.8% vs 24.7% with context controlled"}],"sources":["desai2022"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"2–4","range":{"lo":2,"hi":4},"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: calls carry no individual acoustic features (C10 signatures))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-COM-6","domain":"Communication","metric":"Drumming structure","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"as reported","field":[{"population":"Eastern chimpanzees, 11 communities","years":"—","value":"median 4 hits per bout (mode 3); mean inter-hit 229 ms"},{"population":"Kanyawara; Taï","years":"1996–1997; 1990","value":"61% of male bouts without a call vs 6%; no females drummed; no individual signature at Kanyawara"}],"sources":["clarkArcadi2004","eleuteri2025"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"as reported","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: drums are single events without hit structure (C10))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-COM-7","domain":"Communication","metric":"Drumming context","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"less drumming in large parties","field":[{"population":"Budongo Waibira","years":"—","value":"−29% odds per +1 SD party size; +99% in display and +87% in travel vs rest"}],"sources":["eleuteri2022"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"less drumming in large parties","range":null,"note":"","mean":0.1321,"perSeed":[0.1304,0.1564,0.1122,0.1777,0.0835],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.1387}},{"id":"T-COM-8","domain":"Communication","metric":"Food calls","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"L","units":"fraction of fruit-feeding events","basis":"Taï; audience effect held out","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"—","value":"food calls at about half of feeding events; more males present → more calling"},{"population":"Wild males (site not stated in abstract)","years":"—","value":"more likely with an important social partner nearby"}],"sources":["kalanBoesch2015","slocombe2010"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"0.3–0.6","range":{"lo":0.3,"hi":0.6},"note":"","mean":0.8213,"perSeed":[0.8047,0.792,0.8204,0.8096,0.8799],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.839}},{"id":"T-COM-9","domain":"Communication","metric":"Arrival pant-hoots signal status","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"status, not food amount","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"16 months","value":"arrival pant-hoots only from parties with ≥ 1 high-ranking male; unrelated to ripe-fruit amount"}],"sources":["clarkWrangham1994"],"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","flags":[],"band":"status, not food amount","range":null,"note":"0/5 seeds show the pattern","mean":0.4432,"perSeed":[0.4016,0.4008,0.4922,0.4643,0.457],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"fail","mean":0.4181}},{"id":"T-COM-10","domain":"Communication","metric":"Gesture repertoire","role":"fitted","encoded":false,"evidence":"H","units":"pattern","basis":"core repertoire fitted; juvenile > adult repertoire held out","field":[{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"2007-2009","value":"66 types; individual mean 10.0 ± 8.9 (1–41); juveniles 15.1, adults 5.1"},{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"—","value":"19 meanings; 4.6 ± 3.0 meanings per gesture"}],"sources":["hobaiterByrne2011","hobaiterByrne2014"],"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","flags":[],"band":"core repertoire fitted; juvenile > adult repertoire held out","range":null,"note":"n/a (mechanism missing: no gestures (C10))","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":{"verdict":"n/a","key":"n/a","mean":null}},{"id":"T-COM-11","domain":"Communication","metric":"Alarm calls track audience knowledge","role":"fitted","encoded":true,"evidence":"H","units":"fraction","basis":"one site","field":[{"population":"Budongo Sonso","years":"2008-2010","value":"alert hoos in 46/111 encounters (41.4%); receiver knowledge lowers calling (−0.96, p = 0.030)"}],"sources":["crockford2012"],"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","flags":["revised post hoc"],"band":"0.25–0.55","range":{"lo":0.25,"hi":0.55},"note":"","mean":0.03697,"perSeed":[0.0678,0.03922,0.04082,0,0.03704],"fresh":{"verdict":"fail","key":"encoded","mean":0.04963}},{"id":"T-DEM-16","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Survival of daughters orphaned at 5–9.99 y","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"direction only: HR > 1 (90% lower bound > 1); insufficient below 300 orphan-years or 10 orphan deaths","field":[{"population":"Gombe (two communities)","years":"over 50 y of demographic records","value":"females orphaned at 0–4.99 and 5–9.99 y survived less than non-orphans"}],"sources":["stanton2020"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-17","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Sex difference in the survival cost of maternal loss at 10–14.99 y","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"log HR(sons) − log HR(daughters) at 10–14.99 y > 0 (90% lower bound > 0); insufficient below 200 orphan-years or 10 orphan deaths per sex, or a daughters' HR interval wider than 4-fold","field":[{"population":"Gombe (two communities)","years":"over 50 y of demographic records","value":"males orphaned at 10–14.99 y survived less than non-orphans; females orphaned at 10–14.99 y were no more likely to die than non-orphans and lived longer after the loss than males orphaned at that age; males orphaned at 0–4.99 and 5–9.99 y also survived less"}],"sources":["stanton2020"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-18","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Stress activation after maternal loss fades","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"recent orphans above non-orphans; earlier orphans and adult orphan males not different","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"2000–2018","value":"recently orphaned immatures (< 2 y since loss): diurnal cortisol slope 58% steeper (−0.60 vs −0.38), from higher early-morning cortisol; immatures orphaned earlier did not differ; mature males orphaned before 12 showed no consistent difference"}],"sources":["girardButtoz2021"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-19","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Lean-mass proxy: orphans vs non-orphans","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"orphans lower","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"two decades","value":"orphans had less lean mass than age-matched non-orphans (−0.122 ± 0.046 on log SG-corrected creatinine, χ² = 6.376, P = 0.012)"}],"sources":["samuni2020"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-20","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Lean-mass proxy: alpha mother vs other mothers","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"offspring of the alpha female higher than of all other mothers; no gradient required","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"two decades","value":"offspring of subordinate mothers had less lean mass than offspring of the alpha female (−0.292 ± 0.103, P = 0.006); continuous maternal rank not significant (P = 0.093)"}],"sources":["samuni2020"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-21","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Neighbour pressure during pregnancy and offspring survival","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"HR per SD of pregnancy-window pressure > 1 (90% lower bound > 1); insufficient below 30 offspring deaths","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"1997–2016 (54 group-years)","value":"higher neighbour pressure during pregnancy raised offspring mortality (b = 1.025 ± 0.391, P = 0.008; hazard-ratio 95% CI 1.51–4.85; full model LRT χ² = 9.50, df = 4, P = 0.04); maternal rank no effect (P = 0.55)"}],"sources":["lemoine2020a"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-22","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Neighbour pressure: pregnancy window stronger than lactation windows","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"pregnancy-window log HR above each lactation-window log HR","field":[{"population":"Taï (P. t. verus)","years":"1997–2016 (54 group-years)","value":"averaged over the first 1, 2 or 3 years of lactation, neighbour pressure had no effect on survival (P = 0.64–0.80), unlike the pregnancy window (P = 0.008)"}],"sources":["lemoine2020a"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-23","domain":"Life and death","metric":"Aggression received by immatures, by sex","role":"held-out","encoded":false,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"age × sex > 0 and male:female rate ratio > 1 at 4.5–6 y (90% lower bounds); insufficient below 10 immatures per sex with >= 20 h at 4.5–6 y","field":[{"population":"Kanyawara","years":"2005–2017","value":"aggression received rose faster with age in males (age × sex β = 0.115 ± 0.06, P = 0.04); males received more than females by about 4–5 y (about 3× by 5 y); aggression displayed predicted aggression received (β = 2.694, P < 0.001), not mediated by sex; time in parties with or near adult males did not differ by sex"}],"sources":["sabbi2021"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null},{"id":"T-DEM-24","domain":"Life and death","metric":"One-year survival after maternal loss, by age at loss","role":"held-out","encoded":true,"evidence":"M","units":"pattern","basis":"survival lower for loss under 4","field":[{"population":"Budongo Sonso; Gombe; Mahale; Taï (pooled)","years":"various","value":"one-year survival depended only on age at loss (P = 0.017): 42% of orphans under 4 vs 95% of those 4 or older; at Sonso adopted orphans 100% vs non-adopted 25% (Fisher P = 0.024)"}],"sources":["hobaiter2014"],"verdict":"unscored","key":"unscored","flags":[],"band":"–","range":null,"note":"added after this run; scored at the next proof","mean":null,"perSeed":[],"fresh":null}],"generated":"2026-09-30T21:26:02.161Z"}